Mike Bunch’s 1963 replay: Who should be the NL MVP and Cy Young?

image

Mike Bunch, my Illowa APBA League commissioner, just completed his 1963 replay!  This is part of his huge project to replay the entire 1960 decade.

Mike wants your help, though.  Here are the leaderboards for the National League.  Can you make suggestions for who should win MVP and Cy Young?

The AL standings are forthcoming in a future post.

1963    National          League
Player AVG Tm Player SLG Tm Player OBP Tm
Clemente, R. .324 PIT Aaron, H. .602 MIL Mays, W. .394 SFG
Groat, D. .322 STL McCovey, W. .598 SFG Aaron, H. .391 MIL
Aaron, H. .321 MIL Mays, W. .576 SFG Mathews, E. .378 MIL
Wills, M. .315 LAD Clemente, R. .540 PIT Robinson, F. .375 CIN
Santo, R. .315 CHC Williams, B. .537 CHC Wills, M. .372 LAD
Taylor, T. .315 PHI Santo, R. .537 CHC McCovey, W. .370 SFG
Mays, W. .315 SFG Cepeda, O. .526 SFG Williams, B. .365 CHC
White, B. .305 STL Robinson, F. .511 CIN Groat, D. .362 STL
Williams, B. .305 CHC White, B. .507 STL Clemente, R. .361 PIT
Davis, T. .298 LAD Callison, J. .498 PHI White, B. .356 STL
Player Runs Tm Player Hits Tm Player 2B Tm
Mays, W. 138 SFG Groat, D. 206 STL Groat, D. 57 STL
Mathews, E. 122 MIL Taylor, T. 206 PHI Mays, W. 49 SFG
Aaron, H. 121 MIL Santo, R. 206 CHC Williams, B. 49 CHC
White, B. 120 STL Aaron, H. 202 MIL Callison, J. 42 PHI
Williams, B. 115 CHC White, B. 201 STL Gonzalez, T. 37 PHI
Cepeda, O. 104 SFG Flood, C. 197 STL White, B. 35 STL
McCovey, W. 102 SFG Clemente, R. 196 PIT Cepeda, O. 35 SFG
Callison, J. 99 PHI Pinson, V. 196 CIN Clendenon, D. 35 PIT
Flood, C. 95 STL Williams, B. 191 CHC Hunt, R. 33 NYM
Clemente, R. 94 PIT Mays, W. 188 SFG Alou, F. 33 SFG
Player 3B Tm Player HR Tm Player RBI Tm
Groat, D. 18 STL Aaron, H. 45 MIL Aaron, H. 136 MIL
Pinson, V. 18 CIN McCovey, W. 44 SFG Santo, R. 125 CHC
Taylor, T. 16 PHI Santo, R. 36 CHC Cepeda, O. 121 SFG
Clemente, R. 14 PIT Demeter, D. 34 PHI McCovey, W. 120 SFG
Gonzalez, T. 14 PHI Mays, W. 33 SFG Clemente, R. 111 PIT
Callison, J. 12 PHI Cepeda, O. 33 SFG White, B. 108 STL
Flood, C. 11 STL Howard, F. 32 LAD Boyer, K. 107 STL
Javier, J. 11 STL Boyer, K. 31 STL Demeter, D. 104 PHI
Rose, P. 11 CIN Robinson, F. 29 CIN Mays, W. 103 SFG
Alou, F. 11 SFG White, B. 28 STL Pinson, V. 101 CIN
Player BB Tm Player SO Tm Player SB Tm
Mathews, E. 139 MIL Clendenon, D. 134 PIT Wills, M. 56 LAD
Mays, W. 81 SFG Menke, D. 131 MIL Pinson, V. 31 CIN
Aaron, H. 76 MIL Goss, H. 129 HOU Davis, W. 28 LAD
Schofield, D. 69 PIT Brock, L. 128 CHC Aaron, H. 26 MIL
Robinson, F. 66 CIN Mathews, E. 115 MIL Javier, J. 26 STL
Staub, R. 66 HOU Hickman, J. 115 NYM Robinson, F. 24 CIN
Rodgers, A. 63 CHC Mays, W. 109 SFG Maye, L. 18 MIL
Williams, B. 62 CHC Alou, F. 107 SFG Gilliam, J. 18 LAD
Spangler, A. 61 HOU Cardenas, L. 107 CIN Clendenon, D. 16 PIT
Boyer, K. 61 STL Howard, F. 106 LAD Brock, L. 16 CHC
Player HBP Tm Player ERA Tm Player W Tm
Robinson, F. 15 CIN Marichal, J. 1.82 SFG Marichal, J. 27 SFG
McCovey, W. 11 SFG Simmons, C. 2.05 STL Ellsworth, D. 22 CHC
Rodgers, A. 10 CHC Culp, R. 2.07 PHI Drysdale, D. 21 LAD
Hunt, R. 9 NYM Friend, B. 2.14 PIT Lemaster, D. 20 MIL
Cepeda, O. 7 SFG Koufax, S. 2.35 LAD Koufax, S. 19 LAD
Gonzalez, T. 7 PHI Spahn, W. 2.39 MIL Buhl, B. 19 CHC
Davis, T. 6 LAD Nuxhall, J. 2.41 CIN Sanford, J. 19 SFG
Bateman, J. 6 HOU Drysdale, D. 2.43 LAD Simmons, C. 18 STL
Sherry, N. 6 NYM Ellsworth, D. 2.45 CHC Culp, R. 16 PHI
Clemente, R. 5 PIT Buhl, B. 2.59 CHC O’Toole, J. 16 CIN
Player SO Tm Player SV Tm Player SHO Tm
Koufax, S. 305 LAD Face, R. 32 PIT Marichal, J. 7 SFG
Maloney, J. 273 CIN Baldschun, J. 28 PHI Simmons, C. 7 STL
Drysdale, D. 244 LAD Perranoski, R. 22 LAD Culp, R. 7 PHI
Gibson, B. 213 STL Shantz, B. 18 STL Ellsworth, D. 7 CHC
Marichal, J. 205 SFG Elston, D. 18 CHC Koufax, S. 6 LAD
Lemaster, D. 201 MIL Larsen, D. 14 SFG Friend, B. 5 PIT
Sanford, J. 197 SFG McDaniel, L. 13 CHC Drysdale, D. 5 LAD
Jackson, L. 196 CHC Woodeshick, H. 12 HOU Spahn, W. 4 MIL
Ellsworth, D. 183 CHC Shaw, B. 11 MIL Buhl, B. 4 CHC
Nuxhall, J. 175 CIN Worthington, A. 11 CIN Jackson, L. 4 CHC

 

Thomas Nelshoppen

I am an IT consultant by day and an APBA media mogul by night. My passions are baseball (specifically Illini baseball), photography and of course, APBA. I have been fortunate to be part of the basic game Illowa APBA League since 1980 as well as a frequent participant of the Chicagoland APBA Tournament. I am slogging through a 1966 NL replay and hope to finish before I die.

9 Comments:

  1. Mike, I’d give MVP to Aaron who leads in HR, rbis, and slugging and was still 3rd in hitting too.

    As for Cy Young, it’s Marichal in a tough one over Koufax.

  2. Cy is clearly Marichal.
    MVP is tough – McCovey close over Aaron

  3. Aaron is MVP. Marichal gets the Cy Young.

  4. Another county heard from….I like Marichal for the Cy Young as well. Aaron had the best year for a hitter (IMHO), but I would give Mays the MVP with apologies to McCovey.

    Bob

  5. I give CYA to Marichal and MVP to Aaron.

  6. MVP Hank Aaron & Cy Young to Juan Marichal.

  7. The 1963 Colt .45’s might be the worst stock APBA team I have ever seen,

    As demonstrated by this reply.

  8. One more vote for Aaron as MVP and Marichal as Cy Young.

  9. Nice looking replay. Was this played with C&D or computer game?

    I vote for Marichal and Mays (Aaron had a little better #s but Giants won the pennant so tough for me to vote the best player on the 5th place team over Say Hey.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.